Macintosh... The Naked Truth
Author: Scott Kelby
List Price: $19.99
Our Price: Click to see the latest and low price
ISBN: 0735712840
Publisher: New Riders (07 March, 2002)
Sales Rank: 49,740
Average Customer Rating: 3.87 out of 5
Customer Reviews
Rating: 3 out of 5
Funny but flawed
I enjoyed the first few chapters of the book, but as the book wore on the constant harping on how stupid "PC weenies" are really got to me. By the time I was half way through the eighth chapter (which is entirely comprised of childish letters sent to the author and his equally childish replies), I was sick of it and wondering if I should ever identify myself as a Mac user. I don't want to be associated with Mr. Kelby, frankly.I have a different perspective than most Mac users, though, so maybe I'm missing something. For the last five years, I used Linux, then FreeBSD, then Linux again at home. So when I read the whiny (but still fairly humorous) chapter on how little Mac stuff there is at CompUSA, I couldn't relate at all. Heck, as a FreeBSD user, there was *nothing* at CompUSA for me, and as a Linux user, there was maybe one software package in the whole store that would work on my system. So I have little sympathy for my now-fellow Mac users who get so upset that there are merely scores instead of hundreds of titles for the Mac at CompUSA.
As for the Windows-user bashing...well, I've been through that stage already. When I discovered Linux, I became a total snob, saying things like, "I use a *real* operating system" to any self-proclaimed Windows 'power user' asked me what version of Windows I was running. Since then, I moved on, and realized that I don't need to tear down other people's chosen OS. I finally decided that, *because* Linux is great, I have no need to tear down others' choices. I'll be happy to evangelize to anyone who is interested, but that doesn't require me to ridicule them...quite the opposite in fact.
That's the way I feel about the Mac now, too. Of course OS X has all the power, stability, and security of UNIX with all the ease of use of Mac. Of course you get access to tons of free/open source software, plus access to oodles of commercial software. Of course you get rock-solid performance, plus the ability to be sure that a widget you buy at the store will work for you simply by looking for a logo on the box. None of that is true for any other operating system. Mac OS X is clearly the best OS out there, bar none.
But, again, that doesn't mean I have to humiliate those who use other operating systems. I wish Mr. Kelby had toned that down a little bit more...his book would have been much more enjoyable if he had.
After all, if you're using the best of the best, you have no need to tear others down. There's no reason to be defensive. Let the people using those other operating systems look like fools. Rise above it, secure in the knowledge that you've got the best personal computer system ever available. Eventually, if you don't play the "mine's better than yours, and you're an idiot for thinking otherwise" game, they'll get curious as to why you're so sure of yourself. Then you can evangelize gently, introduce them to the ways in which the Mac will make their lives better, and thereby actually /help/ others instead of hurting them.
Then you'd really be "thinking different."
Rating: 3 out of 5
Sometimes insightful & often entertaining
I have to start out by saying, if you use a PC... ummm... try searching in computing with "_____ for Dummies." You won't enjoy this book much at all. However... if you are reading this on your Multi-scan monitor or better yet a flatscreen G4 iMac, you've come to the right place!
This book has it's ups and downs. There were moments that to me sounded "dated" since the iMac revolution made Mac's far more acceptable and OS X started to make people question their Windows loyalty - and Mr. Kelby says from the start that much of the book is comprised of articles he'd written previously and now expanded upon for the book... unfortunately that often means they retain some of that Pre-iMac sensibility. There is also a large section of one chapter devoted to nasty letters he's receieved from the Windows Impaired along with his response. Unfortunately they boil down to little more than name calling on both sides. I wish he'd included letters showing how ill-informed about the Mac OS these people truly are and THEN made fun of their stupidity.
HOWEVER - there's a good side. A REALLY good one. First of all, he has a wonderful, casual writing style you can't help but enjoy. Second, and much more importantly, I came away from this book with a lot more ammunition to use in my efforts to convert friends from their ugly beige worlds.
He offers MANY unique insights into what it's like to live a Macintosh Lifestyle. I was particularly taken with his comparison of owning a Mac vs. PC to owning a Lexus vs. a Ford Escort. Both do essentially the same things, both have A/C, power windows and locks, and get you from A to B etc, etc - The Lexus is more expensive for the "same thing." Still, there are differences FAR beyond the cosmetic. Those of us with an Apple shaped heart understand... and you will be glad you read this book. Most of it anyway.
Rating: 5 out of 5
Mac Addicts Unite!
There are many things in this world a lot easier than being a Mac Addict in a PC World. Even since the advent of the iMac, iPod, the G5, and the iPod mini, Mac Addicts still catch grief from PC users--at least I do. I know that I can't possibly be the only Mac Addict who has been told that my computer is only for graphic artists and the like or that our market share doesn't justify our existence. Well, this book serves as ample ammunition should you ever be caught in the ongoing Mac Addict/PC user war.I would love for every PC user who ever uttered an ignorant comment about Apple products to read this book, but that would be asking a miracle. Sadly, I believe that we Mac Addicts will be the only ones to ever venture upon the factual data so entertainingly illustrated in this book.
While I joke about the PC users, as does this book, in all seriousness, there is a great deal of misinformation concerning Apple's products, and this book goes a long way to doing away with those myths.
Similar Products
The Second Coming of Steve Jobs
Apple: The Inside Story of Intrigue, Egomania, and Business Blunders
Steve Jobs : Thinks Different
Book Index