Overcoming Overeating

Author: Carol H. Munter, Jane R. Hirschmann
List Price: $7.50
Our Price: Click to see the latest and low price
ISBN: 0449003825
Publisher: Fawcett Books (29 April, 1998)
Sales Rank: 7,515
Average Customer Rating: 4.18 out of 5

Customer Reviews

Rating: 5 out of 5
This book brought my life back to me
I'm glad to have this book, and "When Women Stop Hating Their Bodies" Jane Hirschmann and Carol Munter have truly done some excellent work here.

It makes me feel alive, being able to eat what I want without guilt, buying clothes that fit now, and looking in the mirror and liking what I see today. It helps me to live a fuller, more satisfying life. I don't have to live with this compulsive overeating all my life, because this is going to help me eat my way out of an eating progblem...Thank you Carol and Jane!


Rating: 4 out of 5
I believe! I believe! - I think...
The main theses of this book are that diets don't work for the long term, and that if we could return to nurturing self-feeding on demand, the way we ate as babies, we would eventually stabilize our intake and consequently our weight.

Our obsession with diet has gotten us nowhere except crabby, frustrated, and hungry. We obsess about counting calories, points, fat grams, whatever. We no longer enjoy the pleasures of a leisurely meal because we're so busy computing and worrying about excess. If we'd allow ourselves to eat at will, whatever and whenever we want, the fear of hunger would go away and we would allow ourselves to feed naturally, which means in balance and healthfully. We wouldn't match the unfortunate current trend toward anorexic-looking bodies, but we would be healthy and well-nourished. And our obsessions and compulsions with food would disappear - if you know you can have a cookie whenever you want one, you probably won't devour a full bag of Oreos at one sitting and then deny yourself for the rest of the year. If you know that nothing will leave the planet, you can afford to enjoy it in moderation.

This book was an eye-opener for me. Everything the authors say makes sense. And yet, I just can't bring myself to let go of my own little rituals and launch myself into the universe of safe, natural eating habits. So I keep it handy and browse through it a lot - reinforcement, maybe, until the day comes that I can. Until then, I recommend it for people who want a new perspective on their eating habits, and some provocative new ideas to ponder.


Rating: 3 out of 5
If diets don't work, how do I lose weight?
This book mainly contained information that I already read in previous books, similar to this one. Ok - may be dieting is all too tightly tied up to failing to support some imposed image of body size and shape - may be it is bound to fail - may be overeating is not about food but emotions. Even after you learn to accept yourself and deal with the inner emotions, there is still the question of losing weight. Simply biologically, dieting will make you hungry and you'll crave food. Exercise creates hunger as well. Being hungry you'll want to eat. Weight is thus not lost. And restricting can lead to binging relapse. In the end, I was left dissatisfied with this book and many others.

Similar Products

Anatomy of a Food Addiction: The Brain Chemistry of Overeating: An Effective Program to Overcome Compulsive Eating
It's Not About Food: Change Your Mind; Change Your Life; End Your Obsession With Food and Weight


Book Index