The Case Against Hillary Clinton

Author: Peggy Noonan
List Price: $24.00
Our Price: Click to see the latest and low price
ISBN: 0060393408
Publisher: Regan Books (01 April, 2000)
Sales Rank: 83,821
Average Customer Rating: 3.13 out of 5

Customer Reviews

Rating: 5 out of 5
An American Classic
The case against Hillary Clinton is well known. She's a lying, enabling, trashing, condescending, egotistical reprobate--a virtual clone of her spouse. A book devoted to her plethora of negatives could easily get bogged down into pleonastic screed, but this work soars. Anyone who read Peggy Noonan's recent widely distributed op ed piece "Why Did They Do It?" about the government's nazi-style kidnapping of Elian Gonzalez knows that she is nothing short of a maestro with the written word. She does with a paper and pen what Michaelangelo did with a slab of concrete.

Even though Hillary is the title character, Ms. Noonan realizes that the Clintons--unconventional as their marriage may be-- are inextricably intertwined. They may not be the typical man and wife, but they are full-fledged partners in slime whose misery and misdeeds will keep them together unhappily ever after.

Unlikely many political conservatives, the author reveals an initial respect for and hope that the Clintons would prove successful and good for America. Like many liberals (as well as conservatives and moderates) she became disgusted by the profligate shenanigans to which they subjected the country that he was entrusted to guide. The book subtly captures the irony of a militant feminist who demurred disinterestedly while the world learned the perverse details of her husband's sexcapades with an intern barely older than their daughter. Hillary, whose disdain for the uxorial role is well-known, must have boiled over privately that her greatest public support came when she was forced to play the part of a wronged wife.

Especially delectable is the description of a fantasy palaver between Hillary and Hollywood's most powerful magnates at Michael Eisner's house. Although the scene is too bizarre for belief, Peggy perfectly captures the cadence of Hillary and her show biz cheerleaders that readers are completely pulled into the surrealism of it.

Suffice it to say that this is a must read. In Peggy Noonan's magical manner, she masterfully outlines the enigma of the Clintons. Their depravity is their strength. They do not have a willingness to lie; they have a need to. They are experts at believably telling the most brazen stories without any hint of verisimilitude and are equally skilled at condemning anyone who dares to scoff at their nonsense. While Hillary may not share in her husband's unrestrained concupiscence, her lust for power is every bit as potent.

Ms. Noonan has written many great speeches and mind-expanding columns, but this could be her most important effort yet. If it convinces any open-minded, wavering New Yorkers not to select Hillary as their next senator and retire both Clintons to New York, Arkansas, or whatever state draws the short straw, then we will all owe her a huge debt of gratitude.


Rating: 4 out of 5
Peggy vs. Hillary
Peggy Noonan does a masterful job of dissecting Hillary Clinton's motives and strategies. Of course Hillary wants to be President, and, if she achieves that goal, as the author so skillfully suggests, we will find it infinitely more painful than the first Clinton Era. After 8 years of Hillary's self-created and self-promoted image of herself as just about the smartest woman alive, it is refreshing to see other intelligent women pointing out how mundane, ineffective and just plain mean Ms. Clinton has proven herself to be. Ms. Noonan writes beautifully, and her comments regarding Hillary's use of language to obscure rather than enlighten echo a similar and equally beautifully-written essay by Janet Scott Barlow in her book, The Nonpatritoic President: A Survey of the Clinton Years. Both Ms. Noonan and Ms. Barlow have Hillary's number. Let's hope the voters beyond New York do, too.


Rating: 5 out of 5
Star System -- Schmar System
Like the one star fakers, liars and dopes, I have not read this Book ! But I liked the author interview and so am buying it.

Until amazon puts some kind of Proof of Purchase requirement on the ability to review a book, I'll give all the books I am buying five stars so as to average out at least one of the liars.

Review to follow.

Similar Products

Hell to Pay: The Unfolding Story of Hillary Rodham Clinton


Book Index