The Monk and the Riddle: The Art of Creating a Life While Making a Living

Author: Randy Komisar
List Price: $14.95
Our Price: Click to see the latest and low price
ISBN: 1578516447
Publisher: Harvard Business School Press (September, 2001)
Sales Rank: 27,102
Average Customer Rating: 4.13 out of 5

Customer Reviews

Rating: 5 out of 5
For more than just Silicon Valley
This book worked for me on several levels, and I would encourage anyone to read this, even if you aren't planning to start your own company.

First, the book is what I classify as a business adventure - my favorite kind. The overarching framework is a fictional thread about a guy trying to start an Internet business, Funerals.com, with his primary goal of getting rich in 2-3 years. Randy Komisar, the author, uses this storyline to illustrate what he as a virtual CEO/angel investor looks for from people wanting cash for a new business.

But to illustrate how he came to his views (what is important and why), Komisar gives us glimpses into his life, including important roles at successes such as WebTV and failures like GO (see the book "Startup" for more details on this story).

Interestingly, he takes great pride in his adventures at GO, a company that lost tens of millions of dollars and died. This probably illustrates his primary theme, life is about the journey. Don't measure success by dollars in the bank.

The book also works as a great "lessons learned" for life. Komisar, in the fictional part of the story about Lenny and his funerals.com, asks Lenny, "Would you be willing to do this for the rest of your life?" Once again, from Komisar's point of view, life (not just business) is about the journey. But Komisar's question is also very important for making his decision whether a person should receive his funding, recommendation, or help (you will have to read why).

Lastly, the book is very short, and most people will be able to read it in a day or two at most. It works well on a business trip or just as a break between larger books.

A short book with an engaging fictional story, interesting glimpses into the real world of angels, VCs and startups, and some good sage advice about business and life. Not a bad deal.


Rating: 5 out of 5
It's an old concept put into new meaning in the Internet Age
You may not have heard of Deferred Life Plan or Whole Life Plan, but you definitely have come to think about life's meaning and many would have preached you about living for the life rather than earning for the life, though many actually do the opposite. This is an old concept, but the author spent many years of professional experience to finally "taste" it, and he candidly shared that with readers, many of them are probably indulged in the cash in cash out Internet make-riches mentality these days. I'm sure this book can inject a new meaning of professional life to readers, so it did to me.

The narrative short story format made it a very interesting read, I pulled an almost all-nighter (till 5am) to finish the second half. The writer(s) cleverly blended the main story (how Randy was pitched on a online funerals ideas by a would be entrepreneur) with Randy's previous professional lives, back and forth but smoothly, linking it to some well-known storied of the Valley, giving the book a much broader perspective and making it much more convincing.


Rating: 4 out of 5
Took a while to get into, but captured me afterwards
This book by Silicon Valley legend Randy Komisar, beginning with its title, took me a while to get into, I have to admit. I was way into it (page 60+ or so) and still wondering what the big deal about it was. This is the reason why I give it four stars: it takes a while to hook you. But if you stick to it, Komisar has a wealth of experience to share with you, from his first days in the East Coast, litigating, all through his experiences with tech giants such as WebTV, Tivo and Apple.

The main idea presented by Komisar is that you don't need to postpone your life's dream for later, by playing it safe and engaging in what he calls the Deferred Life Plan. To convey this idea, he presents the reader with the process through which he takes Lenny (an entrepreneur at heart, driven by money, who comes to him for advice) in his pursuit to push his Business Plan for Funerals.com into the attention span of some Silicon Valley VC that Komisar knows. Initially a great idea conceived as a community-building scheme, leveraging the Web to assist those in grief due to the loss of a loved one, Funerals.com had evolved into a very basic money-making scheme that didn't have much of a spark to it, tied to the sale of cheaper caskets by leveraging the efficiencies that the Web can bring about.

In the end, if you take away the Silicon Valley specifics, Komisar's point remains not just valid, but a healthy proposition to lead life driven from within, by passion for what you do and pride rooted in leaving a legacy behind you, instead of ambition and short-term gratification. Highly recommended reading for those who are searching for their mission in life, as well as those who are considering pursuing the entrepreneurial path in their lives.

Similar Products

Next: The Future Just Happened
Crossing the Chasm
A Good Hard Kick in the Ass: Basic Training for Entrepreneurs
Protecting Your #1 Asset : Creating Fortunes from Your Ideas : An Intellectual Property Handbook (Rich Dad's Advisors)
Emotional Branding : How Successful Brands Gain the Irrational Edge


Book Index