Undoing Depression: What Therapy Doesn't Teach You and Medication Can't Give You

Author: Richard O'Connor, Richard O'Conner
List Price: $14.00
Our Price: Click to see the latest and low price
ISBN: 0425166791
Publisher: Berkley Pub Group (January, 1999)
Sales Rank: 1,200
Average Customer Rating: 4.72 out of 5

Customer Reviews

Rating: 5 out of 5
It's not a contest! Read both.
Cognitive therapy is an effective method of treatment, one that is so structured that it can be studied because therapists who provide it correctly all do it the same way. Basically its premise is that depression occurs from our distortions in thinking and by changing these distortions, we can cure our depression. So if changing your thinking patterns relieves your depression, cognitive therapy is right for you.

Dr. O'Connor explains this and goes on to recommend Feeling Good as a good resource . Undoing Depression also explains the other ways depression can occur and gives many ways to attack this vicious disease. As I understand it, many mental health professionals believe that feelings and emotions come first and they lead to the distortions in thinking.

But whichever comes first I have found both books by O'Connor (his new Active Treatment of Depression and Undoing Depression) and also the Feeling Good series by Burns to be helpful. When I contacted Dr. O'Connor's pages for advice for family members, he also recommended When Someone You Love Is Depressed.


Rating: 3 out of 5
POSITIVE ATTITUDE, BUT NOTHING NEW!
Having studied psychology and being a counsellor, I agree with the much of what the author has written. His logic and thoughtful insight are obviously born from his credentials, research and experience, which contributes to the positive side of the book.

However, the downside of the book is simply that this "new" theory is, in fact, not new. The author's philosophy that un-doing depression by replacing depressive patterns of thinking and behaving with a more effective set of skills, is sound, practical advice. However, his theory of taking responsibility for your own actions, acknowledging your feelings, and sharing what is troubling you by improving your communication skills has been promoted by many health care and holistic professionals for several years now. It is a theory I, personally, have taught in stress management classes for years. The words may vary, but the same message can be found in many existing self-help books, inspirational books, stress management books and text books. Severe or chronic depression requires professional therapy and often medication, but holistic methods are certainly useful in certain cases. I gave the book a three star rating for its sound content, but the book also lost two stars in the rating because the message was extremely repetitious of many other books. There was simply nothing new here to grab the reader's attention.


Rating: 5 out of 5
happy happy joy joy
I'm too depressed to write any more.

Similar Products

Depression Fallout : The Impact of Depression on Couples and What You Can Do to Preserve the Bond
Breaking the Patterns of Depression
Feeling Good : The New Mood Therapy
Self-Coaching: How to Heal Anxiety and Depression
What To Do When Someone You Love Is Depressed : A Practical, Compassionate, and Helpful Guide for Caregivers


Book Index